But since we seem to like Sleepy Hollow here... "Sleepy Hollow Renewed for Second Season"!
"Fox's twist on the classic Washington Irving short story will run its full 13 episodes this season and, with a schedule already packed, will return next season rather than earn the typical back-nine order.
"The series premiere bowed to an impressive 3.5 rating among adults 18-49 and 10.1 million viewers ... The second outing of Sleepy Hollow lost little steam, just 11 percent, despite big competition from The Voice and CBS comedy premieres.
'The show has proven to be a risk well worth taking — it's a conceptual blast unlike anything else on television and it all holds together with inventive writing and a fantastic cast,' Fox entertainment chairman Kevin Reilly said. 'I can't wait for fans to experience what else is in store for this fall and even more of this wild ride into season two.'"
I had this one pegged for the "too-good-to-last" category, so I'm glad to be proven wrong.
Edit: Also relevant, John Noble has been cast for a major role later this season. (Spoilers regarding his role behind that link.)